

I’ve played a couple of times with a group & I think it starts off super well but I absolutely cannot stand the sailing. It’s well executed looks nice and is slow, painfully boring after you’ve done it once and the wind/current is fidly enough that you can’t just afk or split screen to help pass the time. Also the food mechanic, while initially very cool and well thought out, turns into a colossal pain in the ass. Used to log on and farm (because stuff grows in “real” time over a couple days to get enough food that the group could explore/adventure and we’d just burn through it all in a night. Felt like a part time job.
I find the story of the sequel worse but pretty much every gameplay aspect better. Though worth noting that you can stack multiple elemental statuses in the second one but only one can be triggered (most recent replaces the last) and this isn’t made as clear as it should be.